The Limitation of an Auditior's Liability in South Africa

Inhaltsverzeichnis (Table of Contents)

• CHAPTER 1 – INTRODUCTION
• 1. OVERVIEW
• 2. THE CASE FOR REFORM
• 2.1. Project 70 - Limitation of Professional Liability
• 2.2. Further Information
• 2.3. Financial Crises
• 2.4. Inherent Limitations of an Audit
• 2.5. Importance of auditor liability
• 3. RESEARCH PROBLEM AND RESEARCH QUESTION
• 3.1. Concerns
• 3.1.1.Concern 1
• 3.1.2.Concern 2
• 3.1.3.Concern 3
• 3.1.4.Concern 4
• 3.2. Summary
• 4. CONTRIBUTION TO KNOWLEDGE IN THE AREA OF RESEARCH
• 5. AIMS AND OBJECTIVES
• 6. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
• 7. ASSUMPTIONS OF THE STUDY
• 8. LIMITATIONS OF STUDY
• 9. INTERNATIONAL JURISDICTIONS
• 9.1. Australia
• 9.2. Germany
• 9.3. United Kingdom
• 9.4. United States of America
• 10. STRUCTURE OF DISSERTATION
• 10.1.Chapter Two: Context and Policy Analysis
• 10.2.Chapter Three: Regulatory Framework: South Africa
• 10.3.Chapter Four: The Legal Liability of Auditors in South Africa
• 10.4.Chapter Five: Regulatory Framework: International Jurisdictions
• 10.5.Chapter Six: The Legal Liability of Auditors in International Jurisdictions
• 10.6.Chapter Seven: Comparative Analysis
• 10.7.Chapter Eight: Analysis of Proposals
• 10.8.Chapter Nine: Conclusions and Recommendations
• 11. SUMMARY
• CHAPTER 2 - CONTEXT AND POLICY ANALYSIS
• 1. OVERVIEW
• 2. THE AUDIT PROCESS
• 3. AUDITOR LIABILITY IN CONTEXT
• 4. POLICY ANALYSIS
• 5. SUMMARY
• CHAPTER 3 - REGULATORY FRAMEWORK: SOUTH AFRICA
• 1. OVERVIEW
• 2. THE COMPANIES ACT, 2008
• 2.1. Appointment of Auditor
• 2.2. Rights and Restricted Functions of Auditors
• 2.3. Collective Actions
• 2.4. Annual General Meeting
• 2.5. Civil Action
• 2.6. Independence
• 3. THE AUDITING PROFESSION ACT, 2005
• 3.1. Registration of Individual Auditors
• 3.2. Registration of Firms as Registered Auditors
• 3.3. Termination of registration
• 3.4. Conduct by and Liability of Registered Auditors
• 3.4.1.Practice
• 3.4.2.Duties in Relation to Audit
• 3.4.3.Duty to report on irregularities
• 3.5. Limitation of Liability
• 3.6. Accountability of Registered Auditors
• 3.6.1.Inspections
• 3.6.2.Investigation of Charge of Improper Conduct
• 3.6.3.Disclaimer of Liability by an Auditor
• 4. SUMMARY
• CHAPTER 4 - THE LEGAL LIABILITY OF AUDITORS IN SOUTH AFRICA
• 1. OVERVIEW
• 2. SOURCES OF THE AUDITOR'S DUTIES
• 3. CIVIL LIABILITY TOWARDS THE COMPANY
• 3.1. Performance Standard in Execution of Duties
• 3.2. Concept of Reasonable Care and Skill
• 3.3. What Constitutes Reasonable Care and Skill
• 4. RESPONSIBILITY FOR WORK OF TRAINEES
• 5. CLIENT COMPANY'S CIVIL REMEDIES AGAINST ITS AUDITOR
• 5.1.1.Actions Available
• 5.1.2.Breach of Contract
• 5.1.3.Delictual Action
• 5.1.3.1.Common Law Delictual Action
• 5.2. Breach of a Statutory Duty
• 5.3. Relevant Statutory Provisions
• 6. CIVIL LIABILITY TOWARDS THIRD PARTIES
• 6.1. General Principles For Common Law Delictual Liability
• 6.1.1.Conduct
• 6.1.2.Wrongfulness
• 6.1.3.Fault
• 6.1.4.Causation
• 7. STATUTORY DISPENSATION
• 7.1. When Liable and What Must be Established
• 8. AXIAM HOLDINGS LTD V DELOITTE & TOUCHE
• 9. CRIMINAL LIABILITY
• 9.1. Criminal Offence: Companies Act, 2008
• 9.2. Offences: Auditing Profession Act, 2005
• 10. SUMMARY
• CHAPTER 5 - REGULATORY FRAMEWORK: INTERNATIONAL JURISDICTIONS
• 1. OVERVIEW
• 2. AUSTRALIA
• 2.1. Function of Auditors
• 2.2. Statutory Requirements
• 2.3. Who May Be an Auditor
• 2.4. Registration Requirements
• 2.5. Forms of Practice
• 2.6. Cancellation and Suspension of Registration
• 2.7. Auditor Independence
• 2.8. Auditing Standards
• 2.9. Annual General Meeting
• 2.10.The Duty to Detect and Report Fraud and Irregularities
• 2.11.Collective Actions
• 2.12.Quality Control
• 3. GERMANY
• 3.1. Function of Auditors
• 3.2. Statutory Requirements
• 3.3. Appointment of Auditors
• 3.4. Registration Requirements
• 3.5. Forms of Practice
• 3.6. Cancellation and Suspension of Registration
• 3.7. Auditor Independence
• 3.8. Auditing Standards
• 3.9. Annual General Meeting
• 3.10. The Duty to Detect and Report Fraud and Irregularities
• 3.11. Collective Actions
• 3.12.Quality Control
• 4. UNITED KINGDOM
• 4.1. Function of Auditors
• 4.2. Statutory Requirements
• 4.3. Appointment of Auditors
• 4.4. Registration Requirements
• 4.5. Forms of Practice
• 4.6. Cancellation and Suspension of Registration
• 4.7. Auditor Independence
• 4.8. Auditing Standards
• 4.9. Annual General Meeting
• 4.10.The Duty to Detect and Report Fraud and Irregularities
• 4.11.Collective Actions
• 4.12.Quality Control
• 5. UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
• 5.1. Function of Auditors
• 5.2. Statutory Requirements
• 5.3. Appointment of Auditors
• 5.4. Registration Requirements
• 5.5. Forms of Practice
• 5.6. Cancellation and Suspension of Registration
• 5.7. Auditor Independence
• 5.8. Auditing Standards
• 5.9. Annual General Meeting
• 5.10.The Duty to Detect and Report Fraud and Irregularities
• 5.11.Collective Actions
• 5.12.Quality Control
• 6. SUMMARY
• CHAPTER 6 - THE LEGAL LIABILITY OF AUDITORS: INTERNATIONAL JURISDICTIONS
• 1. OVERVIEW

Zielsetzung und Themenschwerpunkte (Objectives and Key Themes)

This dissertation aims to explore the limitation of an auditor's liability in South Africa. It aims to examine the legal framework governing auditor liability, the current state of the law, and the potential for reform. The research also analyzes the regulatory frameworks and legal liability of auditors in various international jurisdictions, including Australia, Germany, the United Kingdom, and the United States. By comparing and contrasting these different approaches, the dissertation aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the challenges and potential solutions to the issue of auditor liability.

• The legal framework governing auditor liability in South Africa.
• The current state of the law regarding auditor liability in South Africa.
• The potential for reform of auditor liability in South Africa.
• The regulatory frameworks governing auditor liability in other jurisdictions.
• The legal liability of auditors in other jurisdictions.

Zusammenfassung der Kapitel (Chapter Summaries)

Chapter 1 provides an introduction to the research topic, outlining the case for reform in the area of auditor liability. The chapter examines the inherent limitations of audits, the importance of auditor liability, and identifies key research concerns and questions. Chapter 2 examines the context and policy analysis surrounding auditor liability, including an overview of the audit process and its role in corporate governance. The chapter explores the potential consequences of limited auditor liability on corporate governance, regulatory regimes, and investor confidence. Chapter 3 delves into the regulatory framework governing auditor liability in South Africa, analyzing relevant legislation such as the Companies Act, 2008, and the Auditing Profession Act, 2005. The chapter discusses key provisions related to auditor appointment, rights, duties, and accountability, as well as the current state of statutory limitations on liability. Chapter 4 examines the legal liability of auditors in South Africa, exploring the sources of their duties, civil liability towards the company, responsibility for the work of trainees, and the availability of legal remedies for the client company. The chapter also examines the potential for civil liability towards third parties and the statutory dispensation for limiting liability. Chapter 5 provides an overview of the regulatory frameworks governing auditor liability in international jurisdictions, focusing on Australia, Germany, the United Kingdom, and the United States. The chapter examines the functions of auditors, statutory requirements, registration processes, auditor independence, auditing standards, and the duty to detect and report fraud and irregularities in each jurisdiction. Chapter 6 examines the legal liability of auditors in these international jurisdictions, comparing and contrasting the different approaches taken to address the issue of auditor liability. The chapter analyzes the legal framework, common law principles, and specific statutory provisions governing auditor liability in each jurisdiction. The dissertation aims to provide a comprehensive analysis of the legal and regulatory landscape of auditor liability in South Africa and other jurisdictions, contributing to the ongoing debate regarding the appropriate balance between protecting investor interests and encouraging auditor independence. The research will provide insights into the challenges and potential solutions to the issue of auditor liability, and its implications for corporate governance and financial stability.

Schlüsselwörter (Keywords)

This dissertation focuses on the key concepts of auditor liability, legal frameworks, regulatory regimes, corporate governance, and investor confidence. The research explores the interplay between these concepts in the context of South Africa and international jurisdictions, examining the potential for reform and the challenges associated with balancing the interests of investors, auditors, and the public. The analysis incorporates relevant themes such as limited liability, professional negligence, fraud detection, auditing standards, and the role of legal frameworks in mitigating financial risk. The dissertation examines the legal landscape of auditor liability in South Africa and provides insights into the current state of the law, the potential for reform, and the challenges of balancing competing interests in the context of a globalized financial system.